| Adept Swordsman of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 5,000 sprinkles in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Adept Swordsman of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 1,000 strikes in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| An Eye for Grain | Earn 100 grain bonuses in the Carpentry puzzle. |
| Army of Darkness | Celebrate Sea Battle victories alongside 1,000 skeletons. |
| Astral Anchor | Complete 100 constellations in the Navigation puzzle. |
| Atlantean Explorer | Journey into the lost seas of Atlantis! |
| Atlantean Tablet | Be aboard a vessel that sinks in Atlantis. |
| Bashed Shield | Successfully defend 200 settlements from a Viking attack. |
| Battered Shield | Successfully complete 50 Imperial outpost attacks in which your ship is at risk. |
| Beach Comber | Complete your first expedition for buried treasure. |
| Bejeweled Cannon | Fill 100,000 cannons in the Gunning puzzle. |
| Bejeweled Crab | Clear 5,000 crabs in the Bilging puzzle. |
| Bellator's Bane | Win 5 swordfights against Atlantean saboteurs. |
| Blademaster of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 100,000 sprinkles in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Blademaster of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 20,000 strikes in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Bone Brothers | Celebrate Sea Battle victories alongside 25 skeletons. |
| Boots of Bilging | Sublime or higher experience and Able standing in Bilging. |
| Briny Mask | Be aboard a vessel that sinks in the Cursed Isles. |
| Broad Alchemist | Reach Broad experience in Alchemistry. |
| Broad Battle Navigator | Reach Broad experience in Battle Navigation. |
| Broad Bilger | Reach Broad experience in Bilging. |
| Broad Blacksmith | Reach Broad experience in Blacksmithing. |
| Broad Carpenter | Reach Broad experience in Carpentry. |
| Broad Distiller | Reach Broad experience in Distilling. |
| Broad Drinker | Reach Broad experience in Drinking. |
| Broad Forager | Reach Broad experience in Foraging. |
| Broad Gunner | Reach Broad experience in Gunning. |
| Broad Hearts Player | Reach Broad experience in Hearts. |
| Broad Navigator | Reach Broad experience in Navigation. |
| Broad Poker Player | Reach Broad experience in Poker. |
| Broad Rigger | Reach Broad experience in Rigging. |
| Broad Rumbler | Reach Broad experience in Rumble. |
| Broad Sailor | Reach Broad experience in Sailing. |
| Broad Shipwright | Reach Broad experience in Shipwrightery. |
| Broad Spades Player | Reach Broad experience in Spades. |
| Broad Swordfighter | Reach Broad experience in Swordfighting. |
| Broad Treasure Drop Player | Reach Broad experience in Treasure Drop. |
| Broad Treasure Hauler | Reach Broad experience in Treasure Haul. |
| Broad Weaver | Reach Broad experience in Weaving. |
| Bronze Archelon | Participate in the sinking of 5 archelons in Atlantis. |
| Bronze Citadel | Successfully storm an Atlantean citadel. |
| Bronze Ghost Brig | Participate in the sinking of 5 ghostly brigs in the Haunted Seas. |
| Bronze Ghost Frigate | Participate in the sinking of 5 ghostly frigates in the Haunted Seas. |
| Bronze Ghost Sloop | Participate in the sinking of 5 ghostly sloops in the Haunted Seas. |
| Bronze Gorgonyx | Participate in the sinking of 5 gorgonyxes in Atlantis. |
| Bronze Ship Graveyard | Exorcise the ghosts from a ship graveyard within the Haunted Seas. |
| Bronze Spoon | Dig up 500 kilograms worth of chests from buried treasure atolls. |
| Bronze Triketos | Participate in the sinking of 5 triketos in Atlantis. |
| Cannon of the Deep | Complete 50 expeditions to salvage sunken ships. |
| Celestial Sloop | Complete 2,500 constellations in the Navigation puzzle. |
| Champion of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 100,000 sprinkles in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Champion of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 20,000 strikes in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Chilling Chest | Haul 1,250 chests out of the depths of the haunted seas. |
| Corpse Corps | Celebrate Sea Battle victories alongside 250 skeletons. |
| Crumpled Helm | Successfully defend 50 settlements from a Viking attack. |
| Cultist Crusher | Win 5 frays against cursed islanders. |
| Cursed Banner | Set foot ashore one of the mysterious Cursed Isles! |
| Cursed Forager | Forage 500 kilograms worth of chests from the cursed isles. |
| Diamond Cannon | Fill 250,000 cannons in the Gunning puzzle. |
| Diamond Crab | Clear 20,000 crabs in the Bilging puzzle. |
| Eerie Chest | Haul 250 chests out of the depths of the haunted seas. |
| Elite Swordsman of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 25,000 sprinkles in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Elite Swordsman of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 5,000 strikes in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Enlightened Eradicator | Win 50 frays against cursed islanders. |
| Enlightened Forager | Forage 50,000 kilograms worth of chests from the cursed isles. |
| Expert Alchemist | Reach Expert experience in Alchemistry. |
| Expert Battle Navigator | Reach Expert experience in Battle Navigation. |
| Expert Bilger | Reach Expert experience in Bilging. |
| Expert Blacksmith | Reach Expert experience in Blacksmithing. |
| Expert Carpenter | Reach Expert experience in Carpentry. |
| Expert Distiller | Reach Expert experience in Distilling. |
| Expert Drinker | Reach Expert experience in Drinking. |
| Expert Forager | Reach Expert experience in Foraging. |
| Expert Gunner | Reach Expert experience in Gunning. |
| Expert Hearts Player | Reach Expert experience in Hearts. |
| Expert Navigator | Reach Expert experience in Navigation. |
| Expert Poker Player | Reach Expert experience in Poker. |
| Expert Rigger | Reach Expert experience in Rigging. |
| Expert Rumbler | Reach Expert experience in Rumble. |
| Expert Sailor | Reach Expert experience in Sailing. |
| Expert Shipwright | Reach Expert experience in Shipwrightery. |
| Expert Spades Player | Reach Expert experience in Spades. |
| Expert Swordfighter | Reach Expert experience in Swordfighting. |
| Expert Treasure Drop Player | Reach Expert experience in Treasure Drop. |
| Expert Treasure Hauler | Reach Expert experience in Treasure Haul. |
| Expert Weaver | Reach Expert experience in Weaving. |
| Featherweight of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 1,000 sprinkles in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Featherweight of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 200 strikes in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Frenetic Forager | Earn a rating of Frenetic while Foraging in the Cursed Isles. |
| Full Steam Ahead | Participate in a voyage and win a Sea Battle. Welcome to Puzzle Pirates! |
| Ghost Fish | Be aboard a vessel that sinks in the Haunted Seas. |
| Glittering Chest | Haul 1,250 chests out of the depths of Atlantis. |
| Golden Archelon | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 archelons in Atlantis. |
| Golden Cannon | Fill 10,000 cannons in the Gunning puzzle. |
| Golden Citadel | Successfully storm 100 Atlantean citadels. |
| Golden Crab | Clear 1,000 crabs in the Bilging puzzle. |
| Golden Ghost Brig | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 ghostly brigs in the Haunted Seas. |
| Golden Ghost Frigate | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 ghostly frigates in the Haunted Seas. |
| Golden Ghost Sloop | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 ghostly sloops in the Haunted Seas. |
| Golden Gorgonyx | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 gorgonyxes in Atlantis. |
| Golden Ship Graveyard | Exorcise 500 ship graveyards within the haunted seas. |
| Golden Spade | Dig up 50,000 kilograms worth of chests from buried treasure atolls. |
| Golden Triketos | Participate in the sinking of 1,000 triketos in Atlantis. |
| Grain Adept | Earn 2,000 grain bonuses in the Carpentry puzzle. |
| Grain Guru | Earn 5,000 grain bonuses in the Carpentry puzzle. |
| Haunted Chest | Haul 50 chests out of the depths of the haunted seas. |
| Heavenly Hook | Complete 1,000 constellations in the Navigation puzzle. |
| Heavyweight of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 25,000 sprinkles in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Heavyweight of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 5,000 strikes in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Hexed Forager | Forage 5,000 kilograms worth of chests from the cursed isles. |
| Hijacked Load | Successfully complete 10 merchant hunt expeditions. |
| Homunculus Humbler | Win 500 frays against cursed islanders. |
| Imperial Captain Insignia | Successfully storm 50 Imperial outposts. |
| Imperial Colonel Insignia | Successfully storm 200 Imperial outposts. |
| Imperial Corporal Insignia | Successfully storm 10 Imperial outposts. |
| Imperial Private Insignia | Successfully storm an Imperial outpost. |
| Incredible Alchemist | Complete an Incredible session of Alchemistry. |
| Incredible Bilger | Earn a rating of Incredible while Bilging. |
| Incredible Blacksmith | Complete an Incredible session of Blacksmithing. |
| Incredible Carpenter | Earn a rating of Incredible while performing Carpentry. |
| Incredible Distiller | Complete an Incredible session of Distilling. |
| Incredible Forager | Complete an Incredible session of Foraging. |
| Incredible Gunner | Earn a rating of Incredible while Gunning. |
| Incredible Navigator | Earn a rating of Incredible while Navigating. |
| Incredible Rigger | Earn a rating of Incredible while Rigging. |
| Incredible Sailor | Earn a rating of Incredible while Sailing. |
| Incredible Shipwright | Complete an Incredible session of Shipwrightery. |
| Incredible Treasure Hauler | Earn a rating of Incredible while Treasure Hauling. |
| Incredible Weaver | Complete an Incredible session of Weaving. |
| Inner Skelly | Use an amulet to turn yourself into a skeleton. |
| Island Hopper | Complete 200 expeditions for buried treasure. |
| Jack-Tar | Complete 200 targets in the Sailing puzzle. |
| Longship Vanquisher | Do the maximum possible damage to an enemy longship while on a Viking expedition. |
| Lost Figurehead | Complete 200 expeditions to salvage sunken ships. |
| Masterful Sea Dog | Complete 40,000 targets in the Sailing puzzle. |
| Middleweight of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 5,000 sprinkles in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Middleweight of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 1,000 strikes in the Rumble puzzle. |
| Overflowing Chest | Haul 6,250 chests out of the depths of Atlantis. |
| Oyster | Pay your last respects to the Old Man from Oyster Island. |
| Pale Runner | Journey into the otherworldly waters of the Haunted Seas! |
| Pilfered Goods | Successfully complete a merchant hunt expedition. |
| Plundered Loot | Successfully complete 200 merchant hunt expeditions. |
| Radiant Jolly Roger | Complete 10,000 constellations in the Navigation puzzle. |
| Reef Raider | Complete 50 expeditions for buried treasure. |
| Sandbar Skipper | Complete 10 expeditions for buried treasure. |
| Savvy Sailor | Complete 4,000 targets in the Sailing puzzle. |
| Seasoned Old Salt | Complete 10,000 targets in the Sailing puzzle. |
| Shattered Swords | Successfully defend 10 settlements from a Viking attack. |
| Silver Archelon | Participate in the sinking of 200 archelons in Atlantis. |
| Silver Cannon | Fill 1,000 cannons in the Gunning puzzle. |
| Silver Citadel | Successfully storm 25 Atlantean citadels. |
| Silver Crab | Clear 100 crabs in the Bilging puzzle. |
| Silver Ghost Brig | Participate in the sinking of 200 ghostly brigs in the Haunted Seas. |
| Silver Ghost Frigate | Participate in the sinking of 200 ghostly frigates in the Haunted Seas. |
| Silver Ghost Sloop | Participate in the sinking of 200 ghostly sloops in the Haunted Seas. |
| Silver Gorgonyx | Participate in the sinking of 200 gorgonyxes in Atlantis. |
| Silver Pickaxe | Dig up 5,000 kilograms worth of chests from buried treasure atolls. |
| Silver Ship Graveyard | Exorcise 50 ship graveyards within the haunted seas. |
| Silver Triketos | Participate in the sinking of 200 triketos in Atlantis. |
| Skeleton Crew | Celebrate a Sea Battle victory alongside (or as) a skeleton. |
| Soggy Chest | Haul 50 chests out of the depths of Atlantis. |
| Splintered Axes | Successfully defend a settlement from a Viking attack. |
| Stomped Shako | Successfully complete an Imperial outpost attack in which your ship is at risk. |
| Sublime Alchemist | Reach Sublime experience in Alchemistry. |
| Sublime Battle Navigator | Reach Sublime experience in Battle Navigation. |
| Sublime Bilger | Reach Sublime experience in Bilging. |
| Sublime Blacksmith | Reach Sublime experience in Blacksmithing. |
| Sublime Carpenter | Reach Sublime experience in Carpentry. |
| Sublime Distiller | Reach Sublime experience in Distilling. |
| Sublime Drinker | Reach Sublime experience in Drinking. |
| Sublime Forager | Reach Sublime experience in Foraging. |
| Sublime Gunner | Reach Sublime experience in Gunning. |
| Sublime Hearts Player | Reach Sublime experience in Hearts. |
| Sublime Navigator | Reach Sublime experience in Navigation. |
| Sublime Poker Player | Reach Sublime experience in Poker. |
| Sublime Rigger | Reach Sublime experience in Rigging. |
| Sublime Rumbler | Reach Sublime experience in Rumble. |
| Sublime Sailor | Reach Sublime experience in Sailing. |
| Sublime Shipwright | Reach Sublime experience in Shipwrightery. |
| Sublime Spades Player | Reach Sublime experience in Spades. |
| Sublime Swordfighter | Reach Sublime experience in Swordfighting. |
| Sublime Treasure Drop Player | Reach Sublime experience in Treasure Drop. |
| Sublime Treasure Hauler | Reach Sublime experience in Treasure Haul. |
| Sublime Weaver | Reach Sublime experience in Weaving. |
| Sunken Ship's Bell | Complete 10 expeditions to salvage sunken ships. |
| Swiped Cargo | Successfully complete 50 merchant hunt expeditions. |
| Swordsman of Sprinkles | Hit an opponent with 1,000 sprinkles in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Swordsman of Strikes | Hit an opponent with 200 strikes in the Swordfighting puzzle. |
| Tattered Flag | Successfully complete 10 Imperial outpost attacks in which your ship is at risk. |
| Toppled Crown | Successfully complete 50 Imperial outpost attacks in which your ship is at risk. |
| Ultimate Alchemist | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Alchemistry. |
| Ultimate Battle Navigator | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Battle Navigation. |
| Ultimate Bilger | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Bilging. |
| Ultimate Blacksmith | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Blacksmithing. |
| Ultimate Carouser | Earn the Ultimate achievement for every Carousing puzzle. |
| Ultimate Carpenter | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Carpentry. |
| Ultimate Crafter | Earn the Ultimate achievement for every Crafting puzzle. |
| Ultimate Distiller | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Distilling. |
| Ultimate Drinker | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Drinking. |
| Ultimate Forager | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Foraging. |
| Ultimate Gunner | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Gunning. |
| Ultimate Hearts Player | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Hearts. |
| Ultimate Navigator | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Navigation. |
| Ultimate of Ultimates | Earn the Ultimate Pirate, Ultimate Carouser and Ultimate Crafter achievements. |
| Ultimate Pirate | Earn the Ultimate achievement for every Piracy puzzle. |
| Ultimate Poker Player | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Poker. |
| Ultimate Rigger | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Rigging. |
| Ultimate Rumbler | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Rumble. |
| Ultimate Sailor | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Sailing. |
| Ultimate Shipwright | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Shipwrightery. |
| Ultimate Spades Player | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Spades. |
| Ultimate Swordfighter | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Swordfighting. |
| Ultimate Treasure Drop Player | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Treasure Drop. |
| Ultimate Treasure Hauler | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Treasure Haul. |
| Ultimate Weaver | Achieve ocean-wide Ultimate standing in Weaving. |
| Unearthly Chest | Haul 6,250 chests out of the depths of the haunted seas. |
| Valuable Chest | Haul 250 chests out of the depths of Atlantis. |
| Vargas Vanquisher | Defeat Vargas the Mad while ashore in the Cursed Isles. |
| Waterlogged Spyglass | Complete your first expedition to salvage a sunken ship. |
| Wizard of Woodgrain | Earn 20,000 grain bonuses in the Carpentry puzzle. |
